We are open Mondays again! Now 7 days a week from 10am to 6pm. We do offer gluten free and vegan pies for orders one day in advance.
$8.50 USD
Apple Pecan Crumble pie is made with two or more varieties of local and/or organic with...
$40.00 USD
Apple Pecan Crumble pie is made with two or more varieties of local and/or organic with...
$40.00 USD
Vanilla pastry cream made with Straus organic milk and sliced organic bananas topped with Straus...
$44.00 USD
Summer fruit is here! Fresh juicy local and or organic blackberries and organic blueberries topped with a...
$8.50 USD
Organic bananas tucked into a bed of homemade bourbon flavored butterscotch cream topped with organic whipped...
$40.00 USD
Sumptuous bourbon flavored butterscotch cream with a dab of organic whipped cream and a sprinkle...
$9.75 USD
Locally grown cheeseburger in the form of a pie. Made with grass-fed beef from Stemple...
$44.00 USD
Cherry Pie! Always delicious, there is nothing quite like a cherry pie. Due to the...
$44.00 USD
Order a pie to be shipped to you or a loved one! Cherry Pie! Always...
$40.00 USD
Can't decide between chocolate and coconut? No problem! Get a Chocolate Coconut Cream Pie. Organic...
$40.00 USD
Rich dark chocolate pastry cream made with organic fair trade chocolate and Straus organic milk...
$40.00 USD
Our Classic Apple Pie is made with two or more varieties of local and/or organic...
$40.00 USD
Our Classic Apple Pie is made with two or more varieties of local and/or organic...
$40.00 USD
Order a pie to be shipped to you or a loved one! Our Classic...
$40.00 USD
Organic coconut milk based pastry cream crowned with Straus organic whipped cream and toasted coconut...
$40.00 USD
A pie fit for The King! A layer of our Peanut Butter Pie filling, sliced...
$36.00 USD
As close to cake as we will get. Made with organic fair trade chocolate and...
$10.00 USD
Give the gift of pie with a Petaluma Pie gift card!This gift card can be used...
$9.75 USD
A wholesome version of a childhood memory. Our Jamaican Beef Patty is made with grass-fed...
$8.50 USD
How could you possibly have a pie shop and not have Lemon Meringue Pie? Yes,...
$40.00 USD
Our pumpkin pie is new and improved! Organic pumpkin, true cinnamon, ginger, clove and vanilla...
$40.00 USD
Our pumpkin pie is new and improved! Organic pumpkin, true cinnamon, ginger, clove and vanilla...
$8.00 USD
Crimini and oyster mushrooms cooked with white wine, tarragon and thyme and mixed with Central...
$40.00 USD
Our little sweet potato pie is not too sweet and spiced with cinnamon, vanilla and...
$8.50 USD
If you always thought Pecan pies were too cloyingly sweet, we may have the pie for...
$40.00 USD
If you always thought Pecan pies were too cloyingly sweet, we may have the pie for...
$40.00 USD
Order a pie to be shipped to you or a loved one! If you always...
$40.00 USD
Warm up with Pear Ginger Cardamom pie. Made with organic and/or local unsprayed pears, fresh...
$40.00 USD
Warm up with Pear Ginger Cardamom pie. Made with organic and/or local unsprayed pears, fresh...
$10.00 USD
Know someone in Petaluma or the San Francisco Bay Area? Give the gift of pie...
$8.00 USD
Organic feta and organic spinach with olive oil and tangy sumac. Order it baked or bake...
$44.00 USD
A sweet-tart flavor combination. Sweet organic strawberries with delicious tart rhubarb in a flaky crust. Strawberry...
$44.00 USD
Order a pie to be shipped to you or a loved one! A sweet-tart flavor...
$44.00 USD
Triple up on summer berries and triple your fun and anti-oxidants! Organic or pesticide free...
