Now we have same day ordering for pickup in the store!
␡
$28.00
Apple Pecan Crumble pie is made with two or more varieties of local and/or organic with...
$7.35
Start the day off right... With pie! Local eggs from Coastal Hill Farm, local cheddar from...
$27.00
Vanilla pastry cream made with Straus organic milk and sliced organic bananas topped with Straus...
$7.35
Local pork from Devil's Gulch Ranch brined and slow-cooked with caramelized red onions and our...
$7.35
This Chilean-style Beef Empanada is made with grass-fed beef from Stemple Creek Ranch, with onions,...
$7.00
Organic bananas tucked into a bed of homemade bourbon flavored butterscotch cream topped with organic whipped...
$7.35
Locally grown cheeseburger in the form of a pie. Made with grass-fed beef from Stemple...
$5.50
Cherry pie in your hand. Cherry hand-pie! Organic tart-sweet cherries make our cherry hand-pies so...
$28.00
Cherry Pie! Always delicious, there is nothing quite like a cherry pie. Due to the...
$28.00
Order a pie to be shipped to you or a loved one! Cherry Pie! Always...
$10.00
Our chicken pot pie is made with Mary's Organic Chicken, carrots, celery, peas, tarragon and...
$7.35
Chicken Tinga is a slightly spicy, smoky and delicious treat packed with Mary’s organic chicken,...
$32.00
Order a pie to be shipped to you or a loved one! Organic pecans, organic...
$2.50
What makes our chocolate chip cookies so good? Is it the local organic butter from...
$27.00
We know it's not pie, but our cookies are so yummy! What makes our chocolate...
$27.00
Rich dark chocolate pastry cream made with organic fair trade chocolate and Straus organic milk...
$27.00
Our Classic Appe Pie is made with two or more varieties of local and/or organic...
$27.00
Order a pie to be shipped to you or a loved one! Our Classic Appe...
$27.00
Organic coconut milk based pastry cream crowned with Straus organic whipped cream and toasted coconut...
$7.35
Cornish Pasties (pronounced past-ees) are from Cornwall, UK. A convenient food to bring with you...
$5.95
A delicious way to eat healthy vegetables! Organic cauliflower, chickpeas, tomatoes, onions, garlic, ginger and our...
$32.00
Organic pecans, organic fair trade chocolate, sorghum syrup and bourbon drizzled with salted caramel. A...
$12.00
Get it?So chic, so clever, so smart, so dorky. This handsome vitrified coffee cup is...
$30.00
Show the world which side you're on with this Eat Pie Not Cake T-shirt. These...
$27.00
A pie fit for The King! A layer of our organic Peanut Butter Pie filling,...
$35.00
Our Triple Chocolate Cheesecake Pie is made with a rich chocolate chip cookie crust, filled...
$3.00
Do what the cool kids are doing these days. Put our durable, weatherproof vinyl stickers...
$30.00
All the cool kids are wearing these "In Crust We Trust" T-shirts. Don't you want...
$7.35
A wholesome version of a childhood memory. Our Jamaican Beef Patty is made with grass-fed...
$6.50
How could you possibly have a pie shop and not have Lemon Meringue Pie? Yes,...
$27.00
It's a lime pie! Not key lime, we use Persian limes and organic condensed milk...
$12.00
Make a statement! Show the world which side you are on with this militant yet...
$30.00
Make a statement. Make Pie Not War! These shirts are designed by Petaluma Pie and...
$3.00
Do what the cool kids are doing these days. Put our durable, weatherproof vinyl stickers...
$25.00
Our pumpkin pie is new and improved! Organic pumpkin, true cinnamon, ginger, clove and vanilla...
$5.95
Crimini and oyster mushrooms cooked with white wine, tarragon and thyme and mixed with Central...
$25.00
Our little sweet potato pie is not too sweet and spiced with cinnamon, vanilla and...
$30.00
It may look like a plain Jane pie, but Oh My! A chocolate cake-y filling...
$30.00
It may look like a plain Jane pie, but Oh My! A chocolate cake-y filling...
$28.00
If you always thought Pecan pies were too cloyingly sweet, we may have the pie for...
$28.00
Order a pie to be shipped to you or a loved one! If you always...
$12.00
Do you know someone in or from Petaluma that is a cutie pie? Then they...
$30.00
Do you know someone in or from Petaluma who is a cutie pie? If so,...
$10.00
Know someone in Petaluma or the San Francisco Bay Area? Give the gift of pie...
$3.00
Do what the cool kids are doing these days. Put our durable, weatherproof vinyl stickers...
$30.00
Show your love of Pi and Pie with this spiral Pi design featuring a good...
$3.00
Do what the cool kids are doing these days. Put our durable, weatherproof vinyl stickers...
$7.35
Inspired by Chinese pork buns but in a hand pie! Local pork from Devil's Gulch...
