Thanksgiving Pre-Orders are now closed. We will have Pies for first-come-first-serve on Tues 26th & Wed 27th. All new Pre-Orders for Thanksgiving week have been blocked to allow our small team time to prepare all orders and extra. We will be open Mon-Wed 9am-5pm. Closed Thursday. Open Friday 9am-7pm. All Thanksgiving order will be ready by opening on your selected day. Thanks!

Holiday Pies

Home   Holiday Pies Page 1 of 1

Here are some of our most popular holiday pies. Due to the very high volume of orders, only these pies can be ordered in the 9" size for the week of Monday November 25th through Friday November 29th and Sunday December 24th.

Classic Apple Pie - 9"
Quick Shop
Classic Apple Pie - 9"
$40.00 USD
Apple Pecan Crumble With Salted Caramel - 9"
Quick Shop
Apple Pecan Crumble With Salted Caramel - 9"
$40.00 USD
Maple Pumpkin Pie - 9"
Quick Shop
Maple Pumpkin Pie - 9"
$40.00 USD

Old Fashioned Pecan Pie-9
Quick Shop
Old Fashioned Pecan Pie-9
$40.00 USD
My Little Sweet Potato Pie 9"
Quick Shop
My Little Sweet Potato Pie 9"
$40.00 USD
Pear Ginger Cardamom Pie - 9"
Quick Shop
Pear Ginger Cardamom Pie - 9"
$40.00 USD

Gift Card for Petaluma Pie Online Store
Quick Shop
Gift Card for Petaluma Pie Online Store
from $10.00 USD
Petaluma Pie In-store Gift Card
Quick Shop
Petaluma Pie In-store Gift Card
from $10.00 USD