We are open 7 days a week from 11 to 4 for pickup and in town delivery ($4 fee). We cannot accommodate special dietary requests such as gluten free or vegan at this time. Holiday pie ordering is officially available now. The deadline to order for pickup November 24th or 25th is Sunday November 22nd. Due to the extremely high volume of orders we get, we will not be offering delivery for Holiday Pies and selection is limited to our Holiday Pies collection.

Peanut Butter Pie

$29.00 USD

Peanut butter pie used to mean Skippy, Cool Whip, cream cheese and a lot of sugar, but here at Petaluma Pie, we have made it nice and fancy. Organic peanut butter is combined with Cowgirl Creamery's Fromage Blanc and folded with Straus organic whipped cream and topped with drizzled chocolate in a buttery flaky crust.


Next Previous